Verify each finding against current code. Fix only still-valid issues, skip the
rest with a brief reason, keep changes minimal, and validate.

Inline comments:
In @.agent/memory/candidates/graduated/8c5f6349aa87.json:
- Line 5: Update the accepted lesson identified as lesson_4c914783ec46 to remove
direct CURSOR_PR_BODY_HUMAN_OVERRIDE_ACK=1 authorization and mark it superseded
by lesson_8c5f6349aa87, or state that only grant-pr-body-human-override.sh
establishes the acknowledgment; then regenerate the derived ledger so memory
retrieval exposes only the operator TTY-gated authorization path.

In
@.agent/memory/working/CODERABBIT_REVIEW_WAVE_4835024659_4835288649_2026-08-01.md:
- Around line 22-23: Update the logical batch count in the report introduction
from four to five so it matches the defined Batch A through Batch E sections and
the existing commit map.
- Around line 31-33: Update the Markdownlint configuration guidance to state
that cli2 configuration files replace the legacy root .markdownlint.json, while
retaining the required bin/orama-system/.markdownlint-cli2.jsonc per-directory
override; remove the contradictory instruction that cli2 configuration must
exist only at the repository root.

In @.githooks/pre-push:
- Around line 45-51: Update the git diff-tree invocation inside the guard-touch
scan loop to include merge commits, using -m or the intended first-parent diff
mode. Preserve the existing scripts/git/ path filter and guard_touch control
flow.

In `@scripts/cursor/append-pr-body.sh`:
- Around line 126-131: Unify grant validation across both consumers: in
scripts/cursor/append-pr-body.sh lines 126-131, delegate validation to
pr-body-guard-core.py or enforce the same issued-at parsing and 8-hour expiry
rule; in scripts/cursor/hooks/pr-body-guard-core.py lines 49-67, require
operator-grant-v1 to appear on its own line while retaining the shared TTL
check. Ensure both paths reject expired grants and marker mentions embedded in
other text.

In `@scripts/cursor/grant-pr-body-human-override.sh`:
- Around line 6-9: Update the TTY validation condition in
grant-pr-body-human-override so execution is rejected when either stdin or
stdout is not a TTY, requiring both descriptors to be interactive; preserve the
existing error message and exit behavior.

In `@scripts/cursor/hooks/pr-body-guard-core.py`:
- Around line 125-141: Update _shell_segments to split command lines on newlines
and single pipes in addition to &&, ;, and ||. In _segment_denies_pr_body_write,
evaluate all gh api and ManagePullRequest deny patterns before the gh pr comment
and append-pr-body.sh allow rules, preserving the human override requirement for
append-pr-body.sh.

---

Nitpick comments:
In
@.agent/memory/working/CODERABBIT_REVIEW_WAVE_4835024659_4835288649_2026-08-01.md:
- Around line 152-158: Update the “Lessons graduated (this wave)” section to
preserve provenance for each listed theme: include the relevant learn.py command
and result, or link each theme to its graduated candidate and lesson files.
Retain the existing themes while ensuring the report records supporting evidence
and propagation status.

In @.githooks/pre-push:
- Around line 22-65: Extract the duplicated push-range derivation into a shared
range_for_ref helper using the existing upstream_ref and ref OIDs. Update both
the guard-sync scan and the later attribution audit loop to call range_for_ref
with the local and remote OIDs, preserving the current handling for deleted
remote refs and unavailable upstream history.

In `@scripts/cursor/hooks/before-shell-pr-body-guard.sh`:
- Around line 13-42: The guard invocation, fail-closed handling, and directive
parsing are duplicated across both hooks. Add a shared function such as
pr_body_run_guard in pr-body-backup-lib.sh (or a sourced helper) accepting the
guard mode and backup reason, then replace
scripts/cursor/hooks/before-shell-pr-body-guard.sh lines 13-42 with a call using
shell and shell-preflight, and scripts/cursor/hooks/before-mcp-pr-body-guard.sh
lines 13-42 with a call using manage_pr and mcp-preflight.

In `@scripts/cursor/hooks/pr-body-guard-core.py`:
- Around line 70-78: Remove the unused _normalize_github_repo_slug helper and
the BACKUP-related hook branches that parse dead BACKUP| directives while
invoking pr_body_backup_if_needed. Keep the remaining pr-body-guard decision
handling unchanged; do not restore guard emission.

In `@tests/test_check_guard_sync_divergence.py`:
- Around line 131-154: Tighten the assertion in
test_linked_worktree_sibling_discovered to require "pt-linked" in result.stdout,
removing the fallback assertion for "Perpetua-Tools". Keep the existing
return-code and "byte-identical" assertions unchanged so the test specifically
verifies linked-worktree discovery.

Verify each finding against current code. Fix only still-valid issues, skip the
rest with a brief reason, keep changes minimal, and validate.

Inline comments:
In
@.agent/memory/working/CODERABBIT_REVIEW_WAVE_4835024659_4835288649_2026-08-01.md:
- Around line 124-132: Update the Batch F report metadata to consistently
reflect August 2, 2026, including the document title, current branch tip, and
commit map beyond the earlier Batch E tip 88783688; alternatively, clearly label
Batch F as a dated addendum while preserving accurate branch and commit
references.

In @.agent/memory/working/PR_BODY_GRANT_HMAC_MVP_SAGA_2026-08-02.md:
- Around line 4-8: Wrap the overlong Markdown lines in the document, including
the metadata lines containing the branch, trigger chain, canonical plan, and
research entries and the additional violations at lines 163 and 178-179, so
every line is at most 100 columns while preserving the existing wording and
Markdown structure.
- Around line 110-115: Update the verification commands in
.agent/memory/working/PR_BODY_GRANT_HMAC_MVP_SAGA_2026-08-02.md lines 110-115
and
.agent/memory/working/CODERABBIT_REVIEW_WAVE_4835024659_4835288649_2026-08-01.md
lines 170-174 to include tests/test_append_pr_body_grant_flow.py, ensuring the
append-flow regression test runs before recording verification results or pass
counts.
- Around line 3-5: Rename the paired branches to the required
yyyy-mm-dd-NNN-brief-summary format and update every tracked reference. In
.agent/memory/working/PR_BODY_GRANT_HMAC_MVP_SAGA_2026-08-02.md lines 3-5, 32,
78-79, and 157-158, update both branch declarations and repeated references;
update the Batch F branch reference in
.agent/memory/working/CODERABBIT_REVIEW_WAVE_4835024659_4835288649_2026-08-01.md
lines 126-127 and the canonical/mirror entries in
.agent/memory/working/WORKSPACE.md lines 10-11.
- Around line 175-179: Update the active doctrine in
scripts/cursor/hooks/before-submit-pr-body-reminder.sh to describe the v2-only,
hookified grant and remove the CURSOR_PR_BODY_HUMAN_OVERRIDE_ACK exception. Then
review related .agent/memory references, marking obsolete v1/env-override
guidance as historical or updating it to the v2 behavior.

In @.agent/memory/working/WORKSPACE.md:
- Line 38: Update the PT `#320` follow-up in .agent/memory/working/WORKSPACE.md at
line 38 and .agent/memory/working/PR_BODY_GRANT_HMAC_MVP_SAGA_2026-08-02.md at
line 177 to state that PR body writes require an operator-minted v2 grant:
without one, use ManagePullRequest post_comment only; with one, use
append-pr-body.sh and the exact granted content.

In `@scripts/cursor/append-pr-body.sh`:
- Around line 244-262: Update the state tracking around the `gh pr edit`,
`mark_cmd`, and `consume_cmd` flow so a successful PR body update records that
the remote mutation has occurred before finalization begins. Ensure the
`release_on_fail` trap does not release the reservation after `gh pr edit`
succeeds, even if either finalization command fails, while preserving release
behavior when the edit itself fails.

In `@scripts/cursor/hooks/pr-body-backup-lib.sh`:
- Around line 63-95: Update the guard runner around pr-body-guard-core.py to
capture stderr separately from the decision output while preserving the nonzero
exit fail-closed behavior. In the guard_output parsing case statement, add a
default branch that sets PR_BODY_GUARD_DECISION to DENY with an internal-error
message and stops parsing, and immediately break after any DENY or failed
pr_body_backup_if_needed result so later lines cannot trigger additional work.
- Around line 51-53: Update pr_body_backup_dir() and the backup preflight to
reject unresolved or unsafe fallback directories instead of defaulting to
${TMPDIR:-/tmp}; only accept an existing TMPDIR that maps to the known-safe
backup tree, and ensure PR body backup is denied before mkdir -p or any write
when that validation fails.

In `@scripts/cursor/hooks/pr-body-guard-core.py`:
- Around line 97-135: Update _shell_segments to split on single pipes in
addition to the existing separators, and reorder _segment_inspect so the gh pr
edit, gh api, and ManagePullRequest deny checks run before the gh pr comment and
append-pr-body.sh allow checks. Add regression tests in
tests/test_pr_body_guard_core.py covering pipe-separated commands, matching the
existing newline cases.

In `@scripts/cursor/pr-body-grant-lib.py`:
- Around line 185-203: Gate the PR_BODY_GRANT_HMAC_SECRET override in
resolve_hmac_secret behind an explicit shared test-mode marker, while preserving
normal environment, Keychain, and fallback-file resolution otherwise. In
scripts/cursor/append-pr-body.sh at lines 121-125, honor GH_BIN only when that
same marker is set and use gh by default; update
tests/test_append_pr_body_grant_flow.py and tests/test_pr_body_grant_lib.py to
set the marker.
- Around line 724-754: Update parse_append_segment to use shlex.split when
tokenizing rest instead of rest.split, preserving shell-style quoted values for
--message and --title; retain the existing option scan and return behavior using
the parsed tokens.
- Around line 702-716: Update mint_grant before digest/signature generation and
ACK file construction to validate repo and pr_number, rejecting values
containing newline or pipe delimiters. Preserve the existing output for valid
values and fail before signing or writing the ACK when either field is invalid.

In `@scripts/git/sync-attribution-guard-scripts.sh`:
- Around line 220-229: Update the synchronization loops for the required PR-body
guard files and cursor_hook_rel to fail closed when a source file is absent:
replace the silent continue with an error report and nonzero exit. If any files
are intentionally optional, separate them into an explicit optional list and
report each skipped entry.
- Around line 231-240: Update atomic_install_file to validate every existing
destination ancestor, including dirname "$dest", and reject symlinked parent
directories before creating its temporary file or moving the installed file.
Preserve normal nested hooks/... installation through the sync loop, and add a
regression test covering a symlinked $target/scripts/cursor/hooks directory to
ensure no file is written outside the target.

In `@tests/test_pr_body_guard_core.py`:
- Around line 42-45: Update test_append_pr_body_denied_without_grant to request
the grant_setup fixture, ensuring the guard uses isolated test state instead of
the real home-directory grant and nonce files. Keep the existing command and
denial assertion unchanged.

---

Nitpick comments:
In `@scripts/cursor/grant-pr-body-human-override.sh`:
- Around line 19-21: Validate that at least two positional arguments are present
before assigning or shifting arguments in the script’s argument-parsing flow.
When fewer than two arguments are supplied, emit the existing usage error and
exit; otherwise preserve the current repo_slug, pr_number, and
remaining-argument handling.

In `@scripts/cursor/hooks/pr-body-guard-core.py`:
- Around line 166-168: Update the return logic in the backup-lines handling
block to use iterable unpacking instead of list concatenation, while preserving
the existing “ALLOW” suffix and fallback return when backup_lines is empty.

In `@tests/test_append_pr_body_grant_flow.py`:
- Around line 36-53: Update the fake gh script in the test setup to scan its
arguments for the --body-file option and use the following argument as the body
path, instead of assuming the path is positional $7. Preserve the existing pr
edit behavior and unexpected-command failure handling.
- Around line 96-113: Extend the test after the append command succeeds by
reading the fake gh PR body file and asserting it contains both “## Follow-up:
test” and “operator note”. Keep the existing return-code, updated-output, and
grant-consumption assertions unchanged; anchor the change in the test flow
around the `consume_check` setup and the fake body artifact.

In `@tests/test_pr_body_grant_lib.py`:
- Around line 130-138: In the replay assertion for verify_grant_for_append,
replace the broad nonce-or-grant substring check with an exact assertion against
the expected replay error message. Keep the existing failure assertion and
ensure the test specifically validates the replay path rather than unrelated
verification errors.
- Around line 49-60: Add TTL coverage alongside test_mint_and_verify_happy_path:
mint a grant, rewrite its issued-at timestamp to older than GRANT_TTL_SECONDS,
and assert verification fails with the expiry error; also add a future issued-at
case and assert the negative-age rejection. Reuse the existing grant fixture and
grant serialization/parsing helpers rather than changing production code.

Verify each finding against current code. Fix only still-valid issues, skip the
rest with a brief reason, keep changes minimal, and validate.

Inline comments:
In @.agent/memory/candidates/graduated/1a6dc6bccad0.json:
- Line 43: Remove the literal “/tmp” from the tracked memory text in
decisions[1].notes and rationale, replacing it with neutral wording such as
“ephemeral worktree names” while preserving the existing meaning.

In @.agent/memory/candidates/graduated/d1f3789d4592.json:
- Line 5: Update the claim around the “Human-authorized” wording to use
“operator-gated” instead, and state that the operator-grant-v2 HMAC authorizes
the append capability without proving human identity. Preserve the existing
distinctions from CURSOR_PR_BODY_HUMAN_OVERRIDE_ACK exports and
operator-grant-v1 plaintext acknowledgments.

In @.agent/memory/semantic/DECISIONS.md:
- Around line 8-12: Fix Markdownlint violations in the changed decision block:
wrap lines 8, 10, 12, and 20 to no more than 100 characters, and insert a blank
line immediately after the **Links:** heading. Preserve the existing decision
content and formatting structure.
- Line 8: Update .agent/memory/semantic/DECISIONS.md at line 8 to replace the
public-flow gh pr edit step with scripts/cursor/append-pr-body.sh, identifying
it as the guarded wrapper that performs the remote edit internally. Update
.agent/memory/semantic/LESSONS.md at line 23 to state that agents must not
invoke gh pr edit directly and may use only append-pr-body.sh after the operator
grant.

In @.agent/memory/working/PR_BODY_GRANT_HMAC_MVP_SAGA_2026-08-02.md:
- Around line 61-64: Update
.agent/memory/working/PR_BODY_GRANT_HMAC_MVP_SAGA_2026-08-02.md lines 61-64 to
state that append-pr-body.sh owns reserve, its internal gh pr edit,
mark-applied, and consume; direct gh pr edit remains denied. Update
.agent/memory/working/WORKSPACE.md lines 41-42 to replace the direct gh edit
reference with append-pr-body.sh or explicitly label it as an internal step.

In @.githooks/pre-commit:
- Around line 27-32: Update the pre-commit hygiene gate around repo_hygiene.py
so that when the script exists but python3 is unavailable, it emits an error and
exits nonzero instead of falling through to check_identity.sh. Preserve the
existing fallback only for clones where the hygiene script itself is absent,
matching the LAN gate’s failure behavior.

In `@scripts/cursor/pr-body-grant-lib.py`:
- Around line 178-180: Extend validation to reject newline characters as well as
pipe characters for both repo and pr_number values. Update _validate_repo_slug
and add or reuse a corresponding validator for pr_number, then invoke these
checks from mint_grant and verify_grant_fields before values reach
_canonical_payload or are written into the acknowledgment fields.

---

Outside diff comments:
In @.agent/memory/semantic/lessons.jsonl:
- Line 981: Reword the rationale for lesson_1a6dc6bccad0 in the tracked
lessons.jsonl entry to describe the scratch-worktree incident without embedding
the forbidden scratch-path literal; retain the existing meaning and use a
neutral worktree label instead.

---

Nitpick comments:
In @.agent/memory/working/PR_BODY_GRANT_HMAC_DECISIONS_2026-08-02.jsonl:
- Line 11: Update decision D11’s canonical HMAC payload to use content_digest
consistently instead of digest, matching the established
content_digest/grant_digest terminology used by the implementation and
golden-vector references. Preserve the fixed field order and UTF-8 signing
contract.

In @.agent/memory/working/WORKSPACE.md:
- Around line 47-49: Separate the test results by repository: in
.agent/memory/working/WORKSPACE.md lines 47-49, label 26 as an aggregate and
list the Orama and PT counts; in
.agent/memory/working/PR_BODY_GRANT_HMAC_MVP_SAGA_2026-08-02.md lines 125-127
and 180-190, identify the repository for each 21-test result; and in
.agent/memory/working/CODERABBIT_REVIEW_WAVE_4835024659_4835288649_2026-08-01.md
lines 171-174, clarify whether Batch G’s 21 tests passed separately in each
repository or in one combined run.

Verify each finding against current code. Fix only still-valid issues, skip the
rest with a brief reason, keep changes minimal, and validate.

Inline comments:
In @.agent/memory/semantic/LESSONS.md:
- Line 29: Update the legacy lesson record identified by
lesson_legacy_df758c2d1245: either restore its superseded plaintext rule and add
superseded_by=lesson_d1f3789d4592 metadata, or remove the duplicate entry
entirely; do not leave the current operator-grant-v2 rule under status=legacy.

In @.markdownlint-cli2.jsonc:
- Around line 13-16: Update the ignores configuration in
.markdownlint-cli2.jsonc so DECISIONS.md, LESSONS.md, and SKILL.md are excluded
only from the intended rule rather than globally; use exact generated paths or a
scoped MD013 override, and ensure bin/orama-system/SKILL.md remains checked by
MD013.